Sunday, November 1, 2009

A. What is the article about?

The article is about how the author believes that even though numerically, women have made great progress in the past years, they have gained very little actual respect. She believes that much of this is the fault of women themselves, as they don't fight for the respect they deserve. The author uses examples such as never having been asked for a raise by a woman, or the snide and degrading comments that many news reporters have made about female politicians and other well-known women. Overall, she believes that in order for women to make true progress, they have to start standing up for themselves and demanding respect as human beings, without being ashamed of their femininity.

B. What do you think about the material/information in this article? How does it seem to fit with our journalism class?

The information is very good. It is very appropriate since we do have a completely female class (not counting Mr. Ayer of course...). The author brings up many good points that aren't traditionally thought of. She is very insightful in talking about how numerical progress isn't the only kind of progress there is. She also did a very good job of using other sources and finding good examples to support her case, which is a very valid lesson since we are all new journalists.

C. What questions are you left with? What kind of articles in journalism would you like to read next?

I wonder if there is a way to measure progress, and not just in the number of women with important jobs. I can't really think of a way to track progress in respect for women at all, since every woman's opinion and how she is treated are different. For instance, I haven't come across as much bias because of my gender, but I'm sure that many women have. I would like to see some way to mark that kind of progress. I thought this article was a good starter for the year. It was interesting to read and well-written. I'd like to see more articles like this!

9 comments:

  1. I agree with your questions about how to measure respect and such, because I'm sure that certain women have gotten farther than others on a scale, but maybe just have not changed the entire world's view- which is a very hard thing to do, even just for a nation! I liked that she used examples and other sources as well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I defidently agree with you when you imply women dont stand up for themselves enough. I think no woman should be ashamed to be a female. whooo femininity!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I loved it when you said that "numerical prgress isn't the only kind of progress there is" There are many different women in the world who offer many different things. Some achievements are better than others, but all are equally important.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree, Maggie, and people need to realize this..

    ReplyDelete
  5. That's a good point, how do we even measure progress. How would you measure it? I would say getting paid equally to men.

    ReplyDelete
  6. but that is numerical... so I don't even know

    ReplyDelete
  7. Yeah, this is true that not all people are the same and that some women have encountered more discrimination than others. It's kind of hard to start a revolution when not all women have the same problems, however, this doesn't help the people who are being mistreated as women. But I do think that we as women tend to let man walk over us, sometimes without realizing it. But this is because we naturally feel smaller, I think.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I thought about this measuring of progress business too. Obviously, it can be tracked in the form of statistics...I just don't think it's completely accurate to base everything off the numbers. Things like respect can't be measured and shown in a diagram.

    Also, I think part of the problem is that we're trying to put all women together in a big group, and it isn't realistic. Everyone's personalities vary tremendously, so it's not fair to say that 'women' feel this way, 'women' need to do more of this or that...not all women have the same opinions or act the same way.

    Sorry Juliette. This was an insanely long comment.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Ugh, Jenny! Long comments are not bad!! You made an excellent point about how women are different and cannot really be grouped together because of it! I love it! It's so true!

    ReplyDelete